Seeds Of Excellence: Seed Development

The process of refining a turf variety for the commercial market takes sweat, and eye for quality and a lot of patience.

The process of developing a new turf seed variety for the marketplace is a long, and to the outsider, painful process.

Each year, university researchers and seed producers start out with great hope, testing literally tens of thousands of varieties, each with the potential to become the next rage for professional use in the lawn. Quickly, however, reality sets in. The researcher begins to stress the plants, testing for a plethora of negative environmental and manmade factors. Thousands succumb to the torture, leaving only a handful of survivors to rival varieties already on the market.

This selection process, while time consuming and difficult, ensures that high quality, durable and good looking turf will be available to the marketplace.

THE HUNT. One of the important ways that turf researchers create breakthroughs is by discovering a new turf plant, referred to as germplasm, to work with. Each germplasm represents a unique set of genetic material, allowing researchers to cross-pollinate it with existing varieties to produce turf with improved qualities.

When researchers look for “new” germplasm, they go on collection trips looking for turf with desirable characteristics, such as heat and drought tolerance and disease resistance.

Turf breeders travel as far as Hawaii, New Zealand, Australia and Asia searching for germplasm. They look for grass plants performing well on sites where they are not usually considered adapted.

“We usually take one or two collection trips each year,” noted Doug Brede, director of research with Jacklin Seed, Post Falls, Idaho. “I would say our collections account for about 5 percent to 10 percent of the germplasm we examine, but it’s an important percentage because it’s always new and unusual.”

William Meyer, director of turf breeding at Rutgers University, New Brunswick, N.J., said the department travels the globe extensively in search of new germplasm. “I spent two weeks in eastern Poland collecting bluegrasses, and we had a scientist in Argentina looking for new endophytes,” he said.

Some collection sites are more unusual than exotic. According to Mike Robinson, president, Seed Research of Oregon, Corvallis, older stands of turf commonly found in cemeteries and historic sites are the best for domestic turf collections.

“We’ve even gone to old Civil War battlefields behind fences where the grasses have been allowed to grow for decades,” said Robinson. “We’re interested in finding samples of turf that were originally brought over from Europe, and the main source of these varieties are very old areas of turf.”

Determining where to search for new varieties is based largely on where the species is thought to have originated, noted Brede. “We took a trip to Wales to look for bentgrass because many botanists believe that is where bentgrass originated.”

International samples usually require a native scientists grow the plants to seed, collect the seed and ship it to the turf breeder in the United States.

Samples collected domestically are easier to handle. They range from a 2-inch square piece of sod to individual turf plants, called tillers. These are packaged and shipped back to the research facilities.

PASSING THE TEST. The next step is the process of testing and selecting the turf varieties, which is both time consuming and extremely tedious. Each sample must be separated into individual grass plants, which are then grown individually. Each plant is observed for a variety of appearance and durability characteristics including color, growth habit, resistance to disease, texture and speed of establishment. Each step in the process is designed to eliminate under-performing varieties.

One of the most important considerations in the first stage of observation is the amount of seed the plant produces. Some of the most attractive varieties don’t produce enough seed to make growing it profitable for the farmer or the marketer. “Turf plants will vary widely in their seed production from many seedheads to none,” said Brede. “Many plants are discarded in the testing process due to poor seed production.”

In The Mix
    Most of the commercially available varieties of seed are not one species or variety of turf, but a blend of varieties.

    For example, you may find that a single bag of turf seed contains quantities of Kentucky bluegrass, perennial ryegrass, tall fescue or fine fescue in different proportions.

    Seed is generally mixed together to form a complementary relationship depending on the desired result, according to Dr. William Meyer, director of turfgrass breeding at Rutgers University, New Brunswick, N.J.

    For example, perennial ryegrass in a mix will provide rapid establishment and traffic tolerance, while Kentucky bluegrass in the same mix will add hardiness and persistence under high environmental stress.

    There are many other logical reasons for the blends available in the market, according to Meyer. “There are some blends that have 5 percent to 10 percent aggressive Kentucky bluegrass blended with a tall fescue because it will reduce the incidence of brown patch and increase density,” noted Meyer.

    Some is known, but there is still much to learn about the compatibility of varieties in mixes, said Meyer. “The NTEP program won’t accept blends, and there really hasn’t been enough research done proving the compatibility of mixes. We need some good, long-term studies.”

The varieties that pass this part of the process are few and far between — as many as 99 out of 100 will be eliminated from the potential pools of new turf based on the initial evaluation.

Those that do survive are either immediate candidates for use in a variety, or allowed to go to seed so that their offspring, called progeny, can be further evaluated. These progeny may also be cross-pollinated with other varieties to create a greater number of plants from which to observe and select. The process of crossing varieties can go on for an extended period of time, according to Art Wick, vice president of research and development with Lesco Inc., Rocky River, Ohio.

“There are many varieties on the market today that are the result of a single cross, and there are many that resulted from multiple crosses over four or five years,” noted Wick. “The selection process from any cross may take five to seven years, or longer, to evaluate the results of the cross.”

One of the turf types that is especially challenging to breed is Kentucky bluegrass. This species reproduces primarily through “apomictic” reproduction — this means that the seed is produced without fertilization. “Many Kentucky bluegrasses exhibit 98 percent apomictic levels,” Wick noted, “which means that at best only 2 percent of the offspring may result from cross pollination.” This also means that the population of offspring plants will be genetically identical to the mother plant 98 percent of the time. For stability, it’s a great asset, but it creates challenges when trying to breed improved varieties of this species.

“Out of 1,000 offspring you may get as few as 20 hybrids that exhibit qualities different from the maternal parent plant, or you may get none,” said Wick.

The next step in the process is placing the varieties in turf plots to see how they perform in real world conditions. One of the biggest limiting factors in field testing is mowing height, according to Brede. “We probably lose 1,000 plants every time we reduce the mowing height ½ inch.”

Eventually, there may only be one or two varieties that survive out of the tens of thousands that are planted.

To get a true gauge of a turf variety’s potential for performance in real world conditions, seed marketers send samples to a variety of locations across the country depending on what needs to be tested.

The National Turf Evaluation Program, coordinated by a central office in Beltsville, Md., is used extensively as an objective source of evaluation. For a fee, NTEP distributes samples of the seed to objective testing sites to be grown and evaluated.

Most seed producers also maintain their own network of testing sites, which include turf areas within office parks, golf courses and athletic fields. The sample areas are maintained just like the rest of the turf area, giving the turf producer a clear idea of how the turf variety will perform for end users in different areas of the country.

THE WINNERS. Varieties that are clearly superior performers through this testing phase move on to production. This requires that the seed be gradually “increased” from a few pounds to 1 million pounds for distribution to farmers.

The seed usually requires two to three generations of planting to reach the quantity needed to begin production. Each planting is closely monitored by the breeders for invasive weeds and other undesirable plants, so the purest possible seed is produced. The final quality of seed, called foundation seed, is distributed to farmers for full-scale production of certified seed.

The author is Managing Editor of Lawn & Landscape magazine.

April 1997
Explore the April 1997 Issue

Check out more from this issue and find your next story to read.